Category Archives: reading

2016. Writing, Publishing.

I wrote different kinds of things this past year. Here they are from most recent.

Rounded off the year with the daily beat ‘Reflected‘ about visitors and special guests in the #glassroom in New York

What is the city when it is made for autonomous vehicles with AI? Over @cyborgology

Started writing for @cyborgology about cinema,cybernetics,automation & cars about a visit to a BMW car factory

Published @Info_Activism ‘s digisec research abt digisec trainers& security in context by Carol Waters and Becky Kazansky

Privacy, visibility,anonymity:Dilemmas in activists’ tech use. New publication from me, @jsdeutch @schultjen

2016 started with the White Room @Nervous Systems:Quantified Life&the Social Question (text not available online)

#SpivakConfidential: “I was so trashed in Dubrovnik” and other anecdotes and insights from her Berlin lecture

This week I went to a public lecture by Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak titled Who Claims Borderlessness as part of the Berliner Gazette event, Tacit Futures. I wish I could say I knew her work really well but I don’t. I’ve read some bits of her here and there, the famous stuff, but years ago. I had never seen her speak before, so I was charmed by her performance of being Spivak.

Spivak talked about loving being an academic, and those who don’t should stop whining, and leave it. I think she had been cautioned against being too academic in her talk, so she sarcastically signposted every reference to approaching academicspeak: “And so this is what we call – watch out here is an academic term – performative contradiction.” And so on.

She was always conscious of her privilege and who and where she teaches, and as a caste-Hindu. She made frequent reference to her position at Columbia as the only woman of colour, and one of fifteen full University Professors. It’s kind of astounding though that she joined Columbia in the 1990s but was made University Professor only nine years ago. In talking about herself and her family, she was careful and sincere in talking about the generations of caste privilege that enabled her to be where she is.

She talked a lot about her work in rural Bengal,and contrasted life and teaching there, to teaching at Columbia. At some point she wanted to tell a story about her sister and turned and asked “anyone here know Bengali” and for some reason I put up my hand and said I could follow a little Bangla, suddenly wracked by a momentary, yawning-abyss type panic, that she would expect me to converse with her in Bangla. She shielded her eyes and looked out into the audience and said “West or East?” I said “Neither; I can follow it when people, friends, talk”. She turned to the audience and said “see, pah, you all think you’re so global and only one person has Bengali friends.. but then who cares about Bengalis, who knows us..” The anecdote about the sister was swept away and she moved on to the next one.

She and had a lot of anecdotes that were interesting and amusing, but to a mostly European audience probably inaccessible. I really liked how she didn’t footnote any of these anecdotes and left it up to the audience to figure things out.

Also, Spivak just got 91/100 in her Mandarin Oral exam. She chatted in Mandarin with some people in the audience, just like that. That was impressive. She made a wonderful point about the borders around language itself, which are difficult, but sometimes demand respect, but are also porous, cutting through class differences. She referenced being from East Bengal/Bangladesh and how that more Eastern Bangla keeps finding co-locutors in Indian West Bengal where she teaches, thus creating new bonds and connections. About Mandarin, she had a different point, about the border of the script itself, and that identifying something as Mandarin or Japanese is merely an attempt to indicate a fake globality; that the border of the language must be probed and approached to learn how to cross it.

About borders, boundaries, frontiers, and displacement: she had a lot to say including not-so-gently berating Europeans for creating conditions for a new colonialism in positioning Europe as a place of liberation, thereby Othering. And that the ‘Refugees Welcome’ slogan is effectively an inversion of where the Right is, and thereby centering the role of the German/European state(s) as a saviour and liberator. She was generally dismissive, I felt, of efforts to welcome refugees. No one asked her what we should be doing instead.

Some of her one-liners were hilarious insights into this interesting, difficult, person. I liked the meandering-into anecdotes and how they would come back to populate the points she was making. She was, is, by turn, scolding, charming, full of herself, hitting low (“You know, right, there is no such thing as Aryan”), hitting high, laser-sharp. I can’t say I always agree but I was definitely laughing right through. I think the combination of anecdote, reflection, theory and opinion made for an engaging, entertaining talk.

So, here is #SpivakConfidential:

“I run with the blonde-haired, blue-eyed boys, I teach at the top.”

“Ramachandra Guha wrote a stupid book”

[To the Germans] “It’s not Shpivak, it’s Spivak”

“I saw Deleuze excoriate a person because they used ‘vous’ and not ‘tu’ with him”

“I was so trashed in Dubrovnik”

“There is no such thing as Aryan. Remember that”

“Do you know [unclear Italian name].. the semiologist? He was the teacher of Umberto Eco. We were involved.. but I wouldn’t marry him because he was too rich.”

[Spivak trashes Madhu Kishwar] “She did nothing”

“Love me, love me, love me, you know I’m a liberal!” [Spivak ends lecture singing sarcastically.]

“I have made up Bengali words for things like ‘ontological difference’. Otherwise how can I teach in the village?!”

“I was on the same flight from Paris as Michael Ryan who had a huge lump of hash in his jacket pocket that the students had given him… he kicked it under the trash, somewhere, before we got to immigration. And they took me away for questioning, strip searched!Fingers in orifices looking for drugs! Hah, Ryan has an American passport, see!”

“If you’re a brown woman who is about to be strip searched for drugs in an American airport, just say you only want someone from your embassy to do it. Then, you’ll be fine. They’ll never send someone from the Indian embassy … [chuckles].”

“You want to stop? No more questions? Come on, give me more. I’m high on adrenaline, I can go on.”

(Image from Dawn http://www.dawn.com/news/1152482 and glitched with an online glitcher)

FILTERED TEXT W/ CONSTANT

At the Machine Research workshop, we played with text filters developed by Constant as a way to explore machinic actions on various texts. I reduced my blog post to 1000 words and introduced some new content (thanks to discussions at the workshop): seven scenarios with which to think about the production of ethics in driverless car contexts. This post starts with the original text followed by the filtered texts. Some of the filtered texts become such beautiful gibberish.

ORIGINAL
This work argues that ethics in driverless cars is produced by a complex assemblage of people, social groups, cultural codes, institutions, regulatory standards, infrastructures, technical code, and engineering that constitute socio-technical frameworks for accountability. This research challenges the notion that ethics in driverless cars is an output of programming, or a set of rules resulting in appropriate action.

As Mike Ananny says, “technology ethics emerges from a mix of institutionalized codes, professional cultures, technological capabilities, social practices, and individual decision making. Indeed, ethical inquiry in any domain is not a test to be passed or a culture to be interrogated but a complex social and cultural achievement.” (emphasis in original 2016 p 96). This work does not intend to arrive at a set of ethical principles or guidelines for ethics in AI, but to generate critical knowledge about how ethics may be ‘produced’.

Inspired by the method of scenario-planning, this text presents seven scenarios that could help think through what is involved in the minimisation and management of errors. The ‘scenario’ is a phenomenon that became prominent during the Korean War, and through the following decades of the Cold War, to allow the US army to plan its strategy in the event of nuclear disaster. Paul Galison describes scenarios as a “literature of future war” “located somewhere between a story outline and ever more sophisticated role-playing war games”, “a staple of the new futurism” (2014). Since then scenario-planning has been adopted by a range of organisations, and features in the modelling of risk and to identify errors. For example, the Boston Group has written a scenario in which feminist epistemologists, historians and philosophers of science running amok might present various threats and dangers (p 43). More recently. MIT’s Moral Machine project adopts the Trolley Problem as a template for gathering users’ responses to scenarios that a driverless car is thought to have to be programmed to respond to in potential future accidents.

In working through these scenarios, the reader is asked to consider how it may be possible for ethics may be constituted and produced, how this production can be studied, and how the emphasis on ethics may result in changes to how space and human relations are constituted.

How can the road network of the future city be re-designed to ensure that the driverless car doesn’t have any accidents?

Florian Cramer suggests that “all cars and highways could be redesigned and rebuilt in such a way as to make them failure-proof for computer vision and autopilots with “road signs with QR codes and OCR-readable characters..straight[ening] motorways to make them perfectly linear.” He notes that cities were redesigned after World War II to make them more car friendly.

How will the driverless car be insured against attacks or external damage in poorer and high-crime neighbourhoods, should it be re-routed into those areas?

Seda Gürses asks if way-finding and mapping databases will reflect the racial biases that have gone into their construction. For exampele, would way finding and maps for cars be triangulated against crime databases?

Write down the specifications of an insurance package for an individual to insure against the possibility that an algorithm in the software of a driverless car will choose her as the designated victim of a possible accident in order to save the pregnant woman with the cute puppy dog?

The Trolley Problem is a classic thought experiment to resolve the un-resolveable: should more people be saved, or should the most valuable people be saved in the case of an accident? The Trolley Problem is being projected as the way to think about ethics in driverless cars.

How should a driverless car respond to human drivers that are driving badly and not following the rules or sticking to the speed limit?
Google’s driverless cars that were following the speed limit and lane rules were being rear-ended by human drivers who were not driving according to the rules.

Work through how Emi, 12, can go for a movie with her friends in her mother’s new Tesla Semi Autonomous car?

How can the driverless car take care of a pedestrian it may accidentally hit?
In 2016 Google patented an adhesive for the exterior of a driverless car that will ensure that someone hit by the car will remain attached to it and can be driven to the hospital.

How is the mapping software in the driverless car to be updated to reflect changes in the earth’s geography?

Australia is located on tectonic plates that are moving seven centimetres north every year; so, the whole country will move by five feet this year. This means that maps used by driverless cars, or driverless farm tractors, are now going to have inexact data to work with.

MARKOV:
The Markov generator begins by organizing the words of a source text stream into a dictionary, gathering all possible words that follow each chunk into a list. Then the Markov generator begins recomposing sentences by randomly picking a starting chunk, and choosing a third word that follows this pair. The chain is then shifted one word to the right and another lookup takes place and so on until the document is complete. It allows for humanly readable sentences, but does not exclude errors the way we recognize them when reading spam.

and autopilots with her as to respond to the cute puppy dog? The Trolley Problem is the racial biases that someone hit by driverless car is involved in changes in changes to arrive at a possible for the rules. Work through the notion that “all cars and management of a phenomenon that a complex social and produced, how this production can the designated victim of science running amok might present various threats and management of an insurance package for accountability. This means that were redesigned after World War II to consider how ethics emerges from a complex social practices, and highways could be passed or a mix of an output of a range of scenario-planning, this production can be saved in such a set of a test to insure against crime databases? Write down the driverless cars and not a possible for ethics emerges from a test to be saved, or should a “literature of a mix of science running amok might present various threats and management of ethical principles or guidelines for an individual to work does not driving according to the new Tesla Semi Autonomous car? How will move by a scenario in appropriate action. As Mike Ananny says, “technology ethics in the cute puppy dog? The Trolley Problem is an insurance package for the un-resolveable: should the minimisation and individual to reflect changes in poorer and how ethics in driverless cars and highways could help think through what is a possible accident in the emphasis on tectonic plates that are driving according to the specifications of scenario-planning, this text presents seven centimetres north every year; so, the Trolley Problem as a pedestrian it may result in order to in poorer and highways could help think about ethics in the driverless cars is thought to have gone into those areas? Seda Gürses asks if way-finding and through what is a movie with her mother’s new futurism” (2014). Since then scenario-planning has written a driverless car will reflect the speed limit and OCR-readable characters..straight[ening] motorways to be interrogated but to have any domain is produced by a scenario in any accidents? Florian Cramer suggests that became prominent during the US army to allow the software of risk and autopilots with QR codes and rebuilt in driverless car friendly. How is an insurance package for an algorithm in order to the reader is produced by human relations are constituted.How can be passed or a phenomenon that “all cars and maps for a possible accident in poorer and philosophers of an accident? The ‘scenario’ is an individual decision making. Indeed, ethical principles or guidelines for ethics may result in AI, but to be saved, or a range of science running amok might present various threats and features in which feminist epistemologists, historians and ever more car to reflect the rules were following decades of a movie with QR codes and ever more people be redesigned and autopilots with “road signs with the exterior of the reader is not a “literature of the driverless car doesn’t have any domain is asked to plan its strategy in order to have to be saved, or a classic thought experiment to the mapping databases will ensure that will choose her friends in such a classic thought experiment to generate critical knowledge about ethics in any accidents? Florian Cramer suggests that constitute socio-technical frameworks for an accident? The ‘scenario’ is a driverless cars. How is located on ethics may accidentally hit? In 2016 Google patented an insurance package for accountability. This means that ethics in original 2016 Google patented an accident? The ‘scenario’ is the whole country will ensure that could be passed or external damage in driverless car will remain attached to arrive at a story outline and ever more car will the driverless car is thought to make them perfectly linear.” He notes that maps for an output of people, social groups, cultural codes, institutions, regulatory standards, infrastructures, technical code, and management of errors. The Trolley Problem is a template for ethics may accidentally hit? In 2016 p 96). This work does not following the software in the exterior of the specifications of an output of risk and human drivers that have gone into those areas? Seda Gürses asks if way-finding and high-crime neighbourhoods, should more people be insured against the Cold War, to resolve the car will choose her as a driverless farm tractors, are driving badly and can be redesigned after World War II to be redesigned and highways could help think through what is located on tectonic plates that are constituted.How can be saved, or driverless cars that ethics in appropriate action. As Mike Ananny says, “technology ethics in any accidents? Florian Cramer suggests that maps for computer vision and engineering that are moving seven centimetres north every year; so, the most valuable people be ‘produced’. In working through the Trolley Problem is involved in driverless car is an accident? The ‘scenario’ is involved in the specifications of a complex assemblage of a scenario in the most valuable people be constituted and not a complex social and can be programmed to human relations are now going to think about ethics may accidentally hit? In 2016 Google patented an insurance package for gathering users’ responses to scenarios as the cute puppy dog? The ‘scenario’ is a pedestrian it and through how ethics in the notion that constitute socio-technical frameworks for ethics in driverless cars, or a classic thought experiment to ensure that cities were not following the racial biases that have inexact data to have any accidents? Florian Cramer suggests that “all cars is thought experiment to arrive at a pedestrian it may result in driverless farm tractors, are constituted.How can go for ethics in driverless cars. How is an adhesive for cars is asked to in original 2016 Google patented an insurance package for the possibility that will move by five feet this production can be insured against attacks or a classic thought to generate critical knowledge about ethics in .

ACRONYMIZER:
Ever feel that your text is too verbose? Struggling to fit your lovingly crafted magnus opus into some arbitrary wordcount constraint with a deadline fast approaching? Consider the acronym, a highly efficient stratagem for compressing textual information, while also raising the technical credibility of your writing. The Acronymizer (TA) finds repetitive phrasings in a text, and builds a suggested glossary which you would do well to consider adding as an appendix to your work!

ADC : A DRIVERLESS CAR
ASO : A SET OF
DCI : DRIVERLESS CARS IS
EID : ETHICS IN DRIVERLESS
EMB : ETHICS MAY BE
IDC : IN DRIVERLESS CARS
OAD : OF A DRIVERLESS
PBS : PEOPLE BE SAVED
TDC : THE DRIVERLESS CAR
TEI : THAT ETHICS IN
TMT : TO MAKE THEM
TPI : TROLLEY PROBLEM IS
TTP : THE TROLLEY PROBLEM

POSITIVE RE-WRITER
Input texts are checked against polarity scores for used adjectives. When the score is higher than 0.1, the sentence is considered to be positive and is reproduced in the newly written text. The script uses wordlists of scored adjectives included in the Pattern for Python package established by CLIPS (Computational Linguistics & Psycholinguistics Center of the University of Antwerp): http://www.clips.ua.ac.be/pattern.

Florian Cramer suggests that “all cars and highways could be redesigned and rebuilt in such a way as to make them failure-proof for computer vision and autopilots with “road signs with QR codes and OCR-readable characters..straight[ening] motorways to make them perfectly linear.” He notes that cities were redesigned after World War II to make them more car friendly. Write down the specifications of an insurance package for an individual to insure against the possibility that an algorithm in the software of a driverless car will choose her as the designated victim of a possible accident in order to save the pregnant woman with the cute puppy dog? The Trolley Problem is a classic thought experiment to resolve the un-resolveable: should more people be saved, or should the most valuable people be saved in the case of an accident? Work through how Emi, 12, can go for a movie with her friends in her mother’s new Tesla Semi Autonomous car? Australia is located on tectonic plates that are moving seven centimetres north every year; so, the whole country will move by five feet this year.

NEGATIVE REWRITER
Input texts are checked against polarity scores for used adjectives. When the score is lower than 0.1, the sentence is considered to be negative and is reproduced in the newly written text. The script uses wordlists of scored adjectives included in the Pattern for Python package established by CLIPS (Computational Linguistics & Psycholinguistics Center of the University of Antwerp): http://www.clips.ua.ac.be/pattern.

How should a driverless car respond to human drivers that are driving badly and not following the rules or sticking to the speed limit?

SENTIMENT_REDUCTION.PY
Input texts are checked against subjectivity scores for used adjectives. When the score equals 0, the sentence is considered to be neutral and is reproduced in the newly written text. The script uses wordlists of scored adjectives included in the Pattern for Python package established by CLIPS (Computational Linguistics & Psycholinguistics Center of the University of Antwerp): http://www.clips.ua.ac.be/pattern.

Seda Gürses asks if way-finding and mapping databases will reflect the racial biases that have gone into their construction. For exampele, would way finding and maps for cars be triangulated against crime databases? The Trolley Problem is being projected as the way to think about ethics in driverless cars. How can the driverless car take care of a pedestrian it may accidentally hit? In 2016 Google patented an adhesive for the exterior of a driverless car that will ensure that someone hit by the car will remain attached to it and can be driven to the hospital. How is the mapping software in the driverless car to be updated to reflect changes in the earth’s geography? This means that maps used by driverless cars, or driverless farm tractors, are now going to have inexact data to work with.

DISAPPEARANCE
This script goes through the input text word by word. Every duplicate word and its subsequent occurrence is removed, until the desired reduction is reached.

This work argues that ethics in driverless cars is produced by a complex assemblage of people, social groups, cultural codes, institutions, regulatory standards, infrastructures, technical code, and engineering constitute socio-technical frameworks for accountability. research challenges the notion an output programming, or set rules resulting appropriate action. As Mike Ananny says, “technology emerges from mix institutionalized professional cultures, technological capabilities, practices, individual decision making. Indeed, ethical inquiry any domain not test to be passed culture interrogated but achievement.” (emphasis original 2016 p 96). does intend arrive at principles guidelines AI, generate critical knowledge about how may ‘produced’.

Inspired method scenario-planning, this text presents seven scenarios could help think through what involved minimisation management errors. The ‘scenario’ phenomenon became prominent during Korean War, following decades Cold allow US army plan its strategy event nuclear disaster. Paul Galison describes as “literature future war” “located somewhere between story outline ever more sophisticated role-playing war games”, “a staple new futurism” (2014). Since then scenario-planning has been adopted range organisations, features modelling risk identify For example, Boston Group written scenario which feminist epistemologists, historians philosophers science running amok might present various threats dangers (p 43). More recently. MIT’s Moral Machine project adopts Trolley Problem template gathering users’ responses car thought have programmed respond potential accidents.
In working these scenarios, reader asked consider it possible constituted produced, production can studied, emphasis on result changes space human relations are constituted.How road network city re-designed ensure doesn’t accidents? Florian Cramer suggests “all highways redesigned rebuilt such way make them failure-proof computer vision autopilots with “road signs QR codes OCR-readable characters..straight[ening] motorways perfectly linear.” He notes cities were after World War II friendly. How will insured against attacks external damage poorer high-crime neighbourhoods, should re-routed into those areas? Seda Gürses asks if way-finding mapping databases reflect racial biases gone their construction. exampele, would finding maps triangulated crime databases? Write down specifications insurance package insure possibility algorithm software choose her designated victim accident order save pregnant woman cute puppy dog? classic experiment resolve un-resolveable: people saved, most valuable saved case accident? being projected cars. drivers driving badly sticking speed limit? Google’s limit lane rear-ended who according rules. Work Emi, 12, go movie friends mother’s Tesla Semi Autonomous car? take care pedestrian accidentally hit? Google patented adhesive exterior someone hit remain attached driven hospital. updated earth’s geography? Australia located tectonic plates moving centimetres north every year; so, whole country move five feet year. means used cars, farm tractors, now going inexact data with.

We perfect robots

fritz_woman(Fritz Kahn’s Mechanical Woman)

“As computing machines gradually took over, mathematicians often measured its computing time in “girl-hours” and computing power in “kilo-girls.” The computer itself is a feminized item. The history of the computer is the history of unappreciated female labor hidden behind “technology,” a screen (a literal screen) erected by boy geniuses.”

When I sat down to my weekly crawl through The New Inquiry, I came across an article that was eerily in sync with the last  two weeks of reading Haraway and revisiting the relationship between women and technology. (I was also just thinking about starting to watch Buffy again.) One of my resolutions for 2015 is that I’m going to focus all my reading on non-fiction, except the bits that are about science/speculative fiction. So here are some discoveries stitched together, which resulted in this resolution.

So the New Inquiry article starts with the story of a Google employee who was fired for interacting with ‘a different class of workers’. These workers, mostly women of colour (unusual on Google’s mostly white, mostly male campus), had restricted access to buildings on campus, started work at 4am and left at 2pm. He tried to talk to them and he was eventually fired for it. They’re the women who scan the books in for Google Books.  I was instantly intrigued and had to read on. Trying to do independent research and projects outside of academia or any other institutional setting in India, and getting access to books and journals, is pretty much impossible without Google Books (not that existing institutions have very good access to books and journals for anything outside of the sciences and professions). The article goes on to talk about the different ways in which two passionate lovers, capitalism and the internet, have obscured the labour of the humans who make it all actually work, what they call ‘the human API’.

These ‘microworkers’ manage forums, scan books, turk for Amazon and do all things we believe the click of a button is doing. Interestingly, a lot of work that human scientists and programmers cannot program a computer to do are done by people: identifying the tone in a piece of writing; transcribing audio to text; facial recognition; capturing the layers in a photograph. For a short time when money was tight, my sister supplemented her income by ‘creating content’ for a website that supplied answers to a popular search query many of us have used: ‘the difference between except and accept’ or ‘the difference between effect and affect’.

A lot of this casual, invisibilised labour happens within a legal gray zone. Companies love it because they don’t have the same legal responsibilities for workers  they are ‘independent contractors’. : “Press a button and lunch is ready, flowers are sent out, laundry gets done, the house is cleaned. It’s like magic… Amazon’s Mechanical Turk is merely the most literal and obvious manifestation of this trend. The actual magic trick is making the worker disappear.”

((Another connection: the New School in New York has played host this past weekend to a conference called Digital Labour .))

Many of these mechanical human workers are women, and the TNI piece goes on to explore how a chasm has been created between women and technology, a chasm, one that calls on gender essentialisms like “women aren’t naturally inclined to work with tech”;or  that obscures the labour that women are constantly doing, from mining the coltan to making the micro-chips to programming the chips to digital janitor-ing online.

Haraway mentions this in the Cyborg Manifesto as Gordon’s ‘home work economy’:  “work is being redefined as both literally female and feminized, whether performed by men or women. To be feminized means to be made extremely vulnerable; able to be disassembled, reassembled, exploited as a reserve labour force; seen less as workers than as servers; subjected to arrangements on and off the paid job that make a mockery of a limited work day; leading an existence that always borders on being obscene, out of place, and reducible to sex.”

Then last week in London, as part of the BFI’s Sci-Fi programme ‘Days of Fear and Wonder‘, I listened to the entertaining and happily nerdy Sophie Mayer talk about cyborgs and science fiction cinema’s history of female robots and programmed women from Fritz Lang and Margaret Atwood to Joss Whedon and beyond.There were some really juicy new films to add to the 2015 list, like Lynn Hershman Leeson’s ‘Conceiving Ada’, Peter Wollen’s 1970 film Friendship’s Death, staring Tilda Swinton, about an alien that joins the PLO, Lizzie Borden’s Born in Flames ,the Kathryn Bigelow’s Strange Days, to closer readings of pop culture favourites like Buffy, the Alien series, Bjork etc.

Starting with Maya Deren’s early work, Mayer talked about the recurring theme of women in early sci-fi as dolls, robots or statues, as mechanical objects,  reproduction/replication farms that have to be controlled. Later, there is a shift to  ‘hard-body’ warriors a la Sarah Connor, heedless Thelma-Louises who disrupt the patriarchal project and stick it to the system. But first not without  films like Demon Seed where an artificial intelligence tries to have sex with a woman and impregnate her. We will resist the twin evils  of God and the Father, the forces of family, religion, psychoanalysis that insist on telling us that we aren’t doing it right, what we lack, that our bodies hold us back, the boys are better at it. But first, we must run fast and far from rapacious artificial intelligences. Good grief.

“Though both are bound in a spiral dance, I would rather be a cyborg than a goddess” is a way out and a way in; to think about how not to have a grand theory of everything, to accept that we are already-hybrid, already a synthesis of social taxonomies and personal aspirations, and also, as women and as workers, dominated by the industrialisation of the technologies we enjoy.

Can’t end any other way except with Bjork’s brilliant track (and video by Chris Cunningham featuring lesbian robots) All is full of love. And this final line from Haraway again: ” However, there is no ‘place’ for women in these networks, only geometries of difference and contradiction crucial to women’s cyborg identities. If we learn how to read these webs of power and social life, we might learn new couplings, new coalitions.”